4 stars
Oh, god, this can't be happening!
I started reading this, thinking it was going to be the typical love triangle between Luke "Sky Watcher", Allison and Luke's brother, Gavin. The story was so much more and Emerson was great at connecting the characters and building on their relationships, not just with Allison and the McDermott brothers, but the relationship between the brothers, as well as the family backstories for each. It makes you wonder who is perfect for Allison, if either one actually is, and I can't wait for the second book to come out. It can't be soon enough for me.